Is Antarctica Hostile and Evil?

Heidi Sherlock

Nicholas Johnson, Big Dead Place, 135-148

In chapter 7 of Big Dead Place the author makes reference to the psychological consequences of the crash of a commercial airliner into Mount Erebus. Two of the salvage workers reportedly became “resentful that because of the crash Antarctica might become anthropomorphized as ‘hostile and evil.’” (137). Johnson seeks to dismiss this idea by balancing the emotional indifference and cruelty in Antarctica with references to violence and carnage in the warm open spaces of North America.

First, Johnson recounts the aftermath of the plane crash. The horrific scenario of passengers “being tossed into nearby crevasses” and turned into “flaming fragments” underscores the unfortunate reality of air travel (136). What then follows is a callous summary of incidental events. Johnson reports that recovery teams availed themselves of, “Some bottles of champagne, wine, beer, and brandy” that “had somehow survived the crash” (136). What must have prevailed here was pure pragmatism, or was it something else? In reference to body bags that held the remains of the deceased, Johnson recounts that, “juices frequently squirted out as the bags burst, and on one occasion a handler who caught the body fluids full in the face earned the admiration of the others as he wiped his face with fresh snow before continuing his job” (138). One can interpret his reaction to indifference or to a defensive maneuver. Either way, there is an obvious repression of emotion. Elsewhere in the chapter Johnson describes instances in which the members of previous expeditions perpetrated acts of cruelty upon animals. Robert Byrd, “disgusted by their eating each other’s shit, ordered a litter of pups killed” and, “Richard Byrd and some other men, standing on the ice edge, stabbed whales with shovels until they bled”(140). Finn Ronne and an assistant tortured two penguins for an hour in an effort to deliver two dead specimens to the Smithsonian Institute (140). While these examples are disturbing, they are not unique to human history or human nature.

 Johnson also focuses on other more distant, yet complementary examples of suffering and cruelty. He recounts the story of Perry, a menacing co- worker who as a child took shots at birds and puppies (140). Interestingly, Johnson writes, “when Perry, who lived two doors from me, put up his first door decoration-a grainy black and white photocopied picture of a deer being hit by a car, its body contorted in the split second just after impact-it was if a famous explorer had moved in next door” (140-141).  Johnson also recounts the viewing of safety program videos, some of which seem to have nothing to do with Antarctica. Or do they? He takes the troubling details of another plane crash, this time United 232 in Sioux City, Iowa and shares that, “witnesses describe how the plane ripped open on impact and some of the passengers, still buckled in their seats, tumbled down the runway end over end, eyes wide open and alive, until they weren’t anymore” (145).  Finally, Johnson shares the events at a restaurant in Texas when, “a gunman drove his truck through the front door and shot people as they devoured chicken and spuds from the all-you-can-eat buffet” (145). In fact, the victims “were consolidated for easier murder” (145). We are obviously left then to consider the relationship between the violence witnessed in great abundance in Antarctica and in the fields and towns of Iowa and Texas.

By introducing vignettes of suffering from beyond Antarctica, Johnson is successful in drawing attention from the fact that the continent is a particularly cruel and violent place. Robert Byrd is really no different from Perry and a plane tumbling across the tarmac in Iowa yields no more or no less potential for human drama than one that slams into a mountain at the bottom of the earth. To Nicholas Johnson, human nature trumps the significance of place.

This entry was posted in Heidi Sherlock, Nicholas Johnson. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Is Antarctica Hostile and Evil?

  1. heyitsmikalinda says:

    Earlier today, I was reading an article discussing the differences between the definitions of words and what they have come to mean. One example was the word “pristine”. It originally meant “wild and untouched” rather than “beautiful and untouched”. Something that seems ugly or cruel could be “pristine” as long as it was in its natural state. When I read this I thought of what you mentioned about Antarctica. Humans perceive Antarctica as being hostile or evil because they are not equipped to live there. Before researchers and explorers arrived it was untamed and beautiful. The violence came later, after the natural order had been interrupted.

  2. janet antony says:

    this is Janet from India. i saw one dream.in my dream there is one book.the title of the book is “CRUELTY OF ANTARCTICA”.in this i seen the sea with full of ice cubes.i went there for research purpose.i saw in the depth of the sea having high peaked ice mountains.and i watched deeply the ice mountains.then only i recognized that is high building which was covered with full of ice cubes.then turn the pages book it would show the past history of that Antarctica before the cruelty.there was one large city having full of people.the children were played in the street yard with more happy.people were doing their normal work.after some days there was a rainy season.and also a snow fall was taken place.after three more days later the street and the buildings were covered with full of snow.the people thought that was normal snow fall season.so they didn’t mind it.the days were moved on.because of high cold the glass doors of the building got damaged and started to broken up.after some more months later the water level of sea got raise and covered the city.that is the “cruelty of Antarctica “.after saw the dream i got fear about the end of the world.i wish to share with somebody.thank you.

  3. mathew says:

    wow nice dream…….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s